Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dave Baxter's avatar

Goddamn, yes, this has been my approach to media/art for a long time. Back in the days of network tv (yeah, yeah, I's old) you just tuned into whatever was on, at whichever point it was on. 20 minutes into a movie, 50 minutes in, maybe it was the third in a series, who even knew? You turned it on and just started watching, because that's what was on. And holy shit did we all fall in love with so many movies and shows via this method. Often because they came across as vastly more intriguing than they actually were. What did that line mean? Who was that specific character? When I would finally watch the whole movie all the way through, most of these gripping moments turned out to have been boringly setup in the parts I missed, nothing mysterious about it at all.

This was true for shows, too - what episode was this? What season? You didn't freaking know, you just tuned in and experienced it.

As a lifelong comic book reader this was something I was groomed for - Fantastic Four issue #242 is on the spinner rack at the grocery store? Well, that's what you were reading. God knows if you'd ever tumble upon #243 a month later or any of the ones before it.

I'm always baffled when people "complain" that they have to watch every Marvel Cinematic everything just to follow the uber-plot. Like they might not realize one character who shows up in one scene was actually introduced in some other tv show or movie. My god, who cares. It doesn't actually keep you from understanding the essentials, or even most of the minutiae.

To this day, I never binge watch anything. I watch most movies in 2-3 sittings. And sometimes, I still love fast forwarding 20 minutes in first, just to see how it plays. Keep the mystery of storytelling alive! And don't make it a job, ffs.

Expand full comment
Dane Benko's avatar

I feel like the James Joyce in order thing comes from when people who start with Finnegans Wake or whatever are like "You can't convince me this dude writes regular, meaningful prose" so it's like, "Look, if you start from Dubliners and go from there you will very clearly see the development from canny regular prose to uncanny experimental art." So it just became a way to do it logistically.

Some of your points remind me of this great line from a rom-com script a friend of mine wrote, where a guy always watches only the beginning and end of When Harry Met Sally because "I don't like the scenes where they argue."

I do love your idea of starting a person with Matrix Resurrections to indulge in the disorientation of it.

And Breaking Bad is a great point too. First (linear) watch thru you're like "Oh no we're watching Walt lose his soul!" Second watch thru you're like "Holy fuck this guy was cracked from the beginning." The actual murders start much earlier than it feels. So you can skip the first watch effect if you start at the end.

One thing I was glad to give up in cinephilia ages ago was the feeling like I "need" to see anything in particular. This goes for canonical classics ("You haven't seen Glengarry Glen Ross??!"), event franchise releases ("Yeah but how do you know you won't like it if you don't watch it?"), or awards season slurry ("But what was your opinion on The Green Book?").

I learned from writing reviews in college that sometimes you get "coverage brain" where you not only feel you have to keep up with the most significant whatever focus (so like recent releases, recent indie releases, briefly I got paid for Japanese movies reviews and felt like I needed to cover every mentionable jedaigeki), but you also feel like you have to perceive the movie in a particularly critical or insightful way. And whereas that can help you to some degree learn how to think of your own taste and values, after a certain point it makes watching a movie a procedure rather than an experience, and for a lot of types of movies that kills the value.

Genuinely speaking, if I was still reviewing movies like I did on IMDb all those years ago, I probably would have hated I Saw the TV Glow. It is NOT plotted well. But it's my favorite movie of the year, because its universe reflects people I once knew. Coverage brain would have killed that for me.

Expand full comment
24 more comments...

No posts