16 Comments
User's avatar
The D Side's avatar

Tom Cruise is a cultist and a creep. Full stop.

Tom Barrie's avatar

Really love your description of Cruise in Risky Business. And I'm stealing the phrase "a brain like a pasta strainer", thank you very much.

This might sound weird but I always think that talking about him is like talking to people, particularly British people, about the royal family. Everyone has a particular take that is informed by a combination of projecting their own personal experience, gossip columns, rumours and public appearances, plus a general vibes-based divining of the tea leaves. Cruise serves a similar purpose for movies in general, I guess - he's a sort of figurehead who's deeply weird and flawed as a human, but whose iconography is important enough that his fans/supporters don't really pay too much attention to that fact. It's the "blind faith"/"begrudging acceptance" that you mention from the public. Success built on illusion, as you say.

My girlfriend hates him and can't watch his movies, because of his off-screen weirdness. Personally I love Edge of Tomorrow too much to disavow him.

Did you like Digger? (I haven't seen it yet.)

Sophie's avatar

Hahahaha yesss to stealing 😂

And yes, totally agree! He's bigger than life in a way which is why I had to draw analogies to him being a religious figure. He really is bigger than life and you can project anything you want on him but he's still "there", asking you to believe in him. It's strange because similar to you, I love some of his films (Edge of Tomorrow stan here too) and his performances way too much and I'd be a liar if I admitted otherwise. But ugh idk his whole "let's save cinema" rhetoric has started getting to me because he's really not doing much to save cinema besides promoting Cruise mania. I hate that he's advocating for the Paramount billionaires and I hate that I only see him promoting other people's work when it's a 200+ movie (e.g. Odyssey and Barbie). That's not saving cinema my bro 😭

Yeah I saw Digger over the weekend. Lots to like -- definitely a big swing. I loved the message overall but I felt like it spoonfed it to me a biiiiit too much with a biiiiit too many monologues. But it's soooo layered, it's hard to not take anything from it. Looking forward to hearing your thoughts!!

Ivelisse's avatar

This is a great piece; I can feel how much Cruise is someone who's perpetually lingered in your imagination, which is relatable. I had to ask myself was I evaluating Digger as a film or was I evaluating Cruise as a star? The ubiquitousness of him is something that always haunts me. It feels as though I knew him before I even knew movies. It's a weird contradiction: something in us is immediately comforted by his face on our screen, and something in us also flinches, is repelled, when we remember everything else. He's made me think a lot about the one-sided relationship we have with certain celebrities and movie stars. The control he wields over his image is, ironically, the one thing that indicates a vulenrability we're not privvy to. That's the appeal of when a Cruise character weeps in a movie, breaks down, says he loves you like he means it: it's the illusion that Cruise is losing control, is opening up to us, and we're seeing a human being we've known for years. It's his greatest magic trick.

Sophie's avatar

Sarah yes!!! I've actually wrote about this feeling in detail in relation to other stars of his caliber as well here: https://share.google/LAIrtDRi1GAyGmHPS

D.L. Holmes's avatar

As much as I love Tom Cruise, I’m also torn about loving him cause there’s something uncanny about him, as if he’s a cyborg trying to pass off as human. That GQ interview he did for Digger feels like something that Kafka might’ve written.

But you can also see why he might choose not to engage with the politics of anything, because it’ll just open a door to asking questions again about his beliefs in psychology or his personal life. The last time he did that in the early 2000s, it almost sunk his career between the Matt Lauer interview and jumping on Oprah’s couch.

Shame, I’d be fascinated to hear what he thinks about things outside the movies.

Sophie's avatar

I can see that but I think now audiences (especially young people) need authenticity to be actually persuaded to get out there and watch something on the big screen. There's something about the flashiness of the role mixed with Cruise as a figure that didn't quite connect with people for sure!

D.L. Holmes's avatar

But it does seem that people are enjoying Digger more than the critics (which is weird, you'd think it'd be the other way around). Still waiting to watch the movie myself, it still hasn't released where I am.

Also, when you say authenticity, is that in reference to the movie itself or the marketing?

Sophie's avatar

I think the "people" that watch it and like it are mostly cinema fans like us. Most people that are casual moviegoers don't understand what the film was about and why Cruise is even in this. I got this feedback from several friends/family when I asked them why they haven't seen the film.

Re: authenticity, I'm referring to both. The marketing, without going into spoilers, is awfully deceiving and overwhelming rather than intriguing. When you see the film, you'll see how the film could have been promoted in a way that makes it look more interesting than say...Don't Look Up.

And in regards to Cruise, yeah I actually think that if he went out of his way to shoutout and take stances on what the film is supposed to convey (even the less political stuff), the film would have gotten a lot more buzz. If you don't want to talk about the politics of your films, then I don't think you're going to do a very good job promoting it. You can't just obstain from its contents and be like haha cinema and popocorn it's all so great!! I'm sure he did less press because of this and why people have no way understanding why they should be watching it in the first place.

D.L. Holmes's avatar

I can't believe us cinema fans have now become categorised as "people" =( Makes it feel like we're an endangered species that needs to be on the UN watchlist.

Yeah, I agree about Cruise's less-than-successful efforts at promoting Digger. It's impossible to talk about a movie that's about climate change and the end of the world without talking about what's actually happening out there in the world. Ironically, while researching the making of Magnolia, something similar happened- Cruise's PR team didn't let him promote the movie that much because it seemed a bad idea to talk about his performance as a sexist misogynist pick-up artist while his marriage to Nicole Kidman was falling apart... and that film flopped at the box office. It's like déjà vu.

In fairness, this was always going to be a tough film to market. Definitely could've been handled better but it can't be easy to promote a movie that asks people to root for a billionaire to save the world for a disaster he caused, when said-billionaire is not Bruce Wayne or Tony Stark.

I suppose the rest of the casual moviegoers will be happy with all the IP that Skydance has promised since that will be familiar to them.

Did you like Digger, though?

Cameron Andrews's avatar

Love this as someone who has always struggled with whether or not I want to say that I love Tom Cruise. I think it's really interesting that you mention his apparent need for control as well as his inability to really publicly promote Digger in any meaningful way. I actually read Digger as at least partially a commentary on the need artists typically have to control their world and their narratives through their art and the troubles that can cause when it comes to actually engaging with the world authentically. I found the role of Markson and Digger by extension a very interesting one for Cruise in that regard. Makes me wonder how far he's willing to engage with this internally as well as with directors.

Sophie's avatar

Great point! I think he's a phenomenally smart guy so he knows the film is all about these things. The point re: Digger and how it is about art/narratives/history documentary -- these are all things I agree with and I would actually argue these are the "easier" things that Cruise could talk about. Though I haven't seen him do that much? But the other side of the coin is the politics of the film and I just don't see him engaging authentically with any of this at all. And audiences these days really want artists to go to town with what they believe in to sell them anything. It's tricky. I see someone like Mark Ruffalo promoting a film like that so effectively!

Joe Morris's avatar

I haven't seen Digger yet but was planning to catch it. The trailers look deranged and I'm not sure they connected with a general mainstream audience, and that coupled with TC's lack of press maybe it never stood a chance. The marketing blitz around the last couple of Mission Impossible's were so OTT that it almost spoiled the cinema experience

Sophie's avatar

Yeah agreed! I think a campaign that's more reflective of what the film is about would make the film more appealing to people. But as I argue in the essay, for that to happen, TC would have to engage with what the film is actually about which is inherently massively political